2. 职称英语
  3. Received feminist wisdom has conceived of history as a male enclave devoid o

Received feminist wisdom has conceived of history as a male enclave devoid o

游客2025-02-19  34
问题     Received feminist wisdom has conceived of history as a male enclave devoid of woman subjects and practitioners, particularly before the twentieth century. As Ann For Freedom put it in 1972, from Herodout’s to Will Durant’s histories, the main characters, the main viewpoints and interests, have all been male. Feminist accounts of the 1970s and 1980s viewed historiography (the writing of history) as overwhelmingly his, coining the term herstory and presenting it as a compensatory feminist practice. Herstory designated women’s place at the center of an alternative narrative of past events. Rosalind Miles’s description restates the popular view: Women’s history by contrast has only just begun to invent itself. Males gained entry to the business of recording, defining and interpreting events in the third millennium B.C.; for women, this process did not even begin until the nineteenth century. The herstorical method provided a means for feminist historians to explore materials by and about women that had previously been neglected or ignored. Herstory promoted curricular transformation in schools and was used as a slogan on T-shirts, pencils, and buttons. Exposing historian’s tacit and intentional sexism, herstorians set out to correct the record — to show that women had held up half the historical sky.
    Despite the great scholarly gains made behind the rallying cry, herstory’s popular myth– particularly about the lack of women who have recorded history–require revision. Herstory may accurately describe feminists efforts to construct female-centered accounts of the past, but the term inadvertently blinds us to women’s important contributions to historical discourse before the nineteenth century. Historiography has not been an entirely male preserve, though feminists are justified in faulting its long-standing masculine contours. In fact, criticism of historiography’s sexism is not of recent origin. Early eighteenth-century feminist Mary Astell protested that the Men being the Historians, they seldom condescend to record the great and good actions of Women. Astell, like those who echoed her sentiments two and a half centuries later, must be credited for admirable zeal in setting out to right scholarly wrongs, but her supposition that historians were only male is inaccurate. Her perception is especially strange because she herself wrote a historical work, An Impartial Enquiry into the Cause of Rebellion and Civil War (1704). Astell’s judgment is at the same time understandable, given that much historical writing by women of the late seventeenth century was not published until the nineteenth century. Despite their courage and their rightful anger, Astell and her descendants overlooked early modern woman writer’s contributions to historiography. [br] Mary Astell is discussed by the author as an example of an eighteenth-century feminist historian
选项 A、who was representative of the intellectual interests of the woman historians of her time
B、who inspired many practitioners of herstory in the twentieth century
C、who shared with modern herstorian’s a mistaken assumption regarding the writing of history
D、whose major work aroused much controversy at the time of its publication
E、whose major work still has not received the attention from scholars that it deserves
答案 C
解析 对应第二段第九句的Astell and her descendants overlooked early modern woman writer’s contributions to historiography，选项的a mistaken assumption指的是早期历史没有包含女性。A项文中未提及。B项很多人觉得该项对应第二段第六句的Astell, like those who echoed her sentiments two and a half centuries later。但是这只能说明20世纪的一些历史学家认同玛丽.阿斯泰尔的观点，但是不见得是被玛丽.阿斯泰尔所启发的。另外，本题是功能题，玛丽.阿斯泰尔作为一个例子，所要支持的作者的观点应该是“认为早期历史研究中没有女性的贡献，这是不正确的”，因此相比之下，选项C更合题目要求。
转载请注明原文地址:https://www.tihaiku.com/zcyy/3964033.html
相关试题推荐
随机试题
最新回复(0)